CarMax Cashes in Big on Used Car Surge, Stock to Watch

CarMax executives admitted that the current market is bolstering sales, but they did not seem concerned about this changing in the near future.

article-image

Source: Shutterstock

share
  • Used cars prices are up 29.7% and CarMax more than doubled its sales volume
  • In June, the average low-mileage used car cost 3.1% less than its brand new counterpart, compared to 10.8% less in November 2020

With used car prices up 29.7% in the last year and the cost of rental cars more than doubling, dealer CarMax is cashing in big. The Richmond, Va.-based company reported that it more than doubled its sales volumes in early 2021 from a year ago. 

CarMax has an expected earnings growth rate of 42.3% for the current year, ending February 2022. The Zacks Consensus Estimate for current-year earnings improved 10.7% over the past week, while the stock price swelled 38.3% year-to-date.

The company is benefiting from this year’s high used car prices. CarMax’s first quarter sales jumped 138%, exceeding analyst expectations. The company more than doubled its unit sales through late May.

In June, the average low-mileage used car cost 3.1% less than its brand new counterpart. In November 2020, used cars were 10.8% less than brand new models, on average, according to data from car-search website iSeeCars.com.

Consumer prices rose 5% for the 12-month period ending in May, up from the 4.2% rise in April, according to data from the labor department. It’s the sharpest increase since August 2008. 

“Our average selling prices were up a couple of thousand dollars,” said CarMax CEO Bill Nash on the company’s first quarter earnings call. “I do think we’re reaching an inflection point. If you look at the consumer price index and the difference between new cars and late-model used cars, that gap has definitely narrowed. While new cars are going up, they have not gone up at the pace of used cars.” 

Used car prices are skyrocketing for a number of reasons. New vehicle production is slowing due to ongoing microchip shortages, which is pushing buyers into the used market. Fewer new models available also means that fewer trade-ins are happening, so the used car supply is not meeting demand. 

“Normally. that pricing environment would be a headwind to just the used car industry in general,” said Nash. “I think the difference this quarter was that because there was a lack of new car availability, I think it pushed customers down into the used car market, which helped to raise the price of used cars.”

CarMax executives admitted that the current market is bolstering sales, but they did not seem concerned about this changing in the near future. 

“There’s some supply constraints out there because you’ve got some different folks doing different things. You also have the demand for maybe some new car customers moving into used cars,” said Nash. “I don’t see a lot changing in supply over the next couple of quarters.”

Tags

Decoding crypto and the markets. Daily, with Byron Gilliam.

Upcoming Events

Old Billingsgate

Mon - Wed, October 13 - 15, 2025

Blockworks’ Digital Asset Summit (DAS) will feature conversations between the builders, allocators, and legislators who will shape the trajectory of the digital asset ecosystem in the US and abroad.

recent research

Research Report Templates (20).png

Research

The dynamic between Ethena, Pendle and Aave exhibits a mutually-beneficial relationship, where the offerings of each business grows the top lines of every party in this exchange. Pendle sits at the intersection of YBA issuers (Ethena) and money markets (Aave), demonstrating heightened utilization rates of YBAs, where the PTs then exhibit profound utilization as collateral. YBA issuers see Pendle as a premier go-to-market venue, often underwriting incentives for liquidity on the market and solving for Pendle’s supply side, while money markets view PTs as attractive collateral types to lend against, solving for Pendle’s demand side. PTs represent a highly profitable collateral listing for Aave, with depositors maxing out the available borrow capacity. Pendle’s recent launch of Boros may now present the most material growth vector beyond what is currently exhibited on V2 markets, offering the ability to price yield, spreads, and duration risk across various points in time out into the future.

article-image

Airlines defend their rewards moat, Binance courts favor over breakfast, DAT fees pile up and systematic thinking

article-image

ETF flows slow, REV stagnates, Pump strikes back and Drift punches up

article-image

We’re beginning to price in the chance of not just a 25 basis point cut, but a 50 bps one

article-image

Does Circle’s Arc threaten Ethereum’s “stablecoin chain” moat, or does EVM gravity pull flows back anyway?

article-image

Tech giant’s part in long-term HPC agreement gives it “more financial certainty” than other deals, consulting firm exec argues

article-image

The new SVM chain Zink uses zk tech and promises universal account profiles