SEC Claims Recent Court Win Weakens Ripple’s Core Argument

In a supporting letter filed Tuesday, the SEC alleged that Ripple’s “fair notice” argument is moot, based on a recent, separate court win for the regulator

article-image

Vector-3D/Shutterstock modified by Blockworks

share

The SEC has claimed that its recent win against broker dealer Commonwealth Equity Services should be taken into account in its Ripple lawsuit, which could end with a summary judgment any day now. 

In a supporting letter filed Tuesday, the SEC says Ripple’s “fair notice” argument is moot, based on a recent court win for the regulator. The SEC successfully shut down this same defense argument in its case against Commonwealth, which it sued in 2019 for conflict of interest violations. 

Ripple’s fair notice defense is based on a recent Supreme Court ruling; Bittner v. United States. 

The US had made a case against Romanian immigrant Alexandru Bittner, who, with 272 bank accounts, broke the law when he failed to file a relevant report with regulators for each one. 

US authorities demanded he pay a $10,000 Bank Secrecy Act fine for each, while the Supreme Court ruled he only had to meet a one-time payment of $10,000. 

“Bittner did not learn of this reporting obligation until returning to the United States many years later. After he returned, he filed the required reports, but not in time to avoid violations,” wrote law firm Faegre Drinker in a recent blog.

The Supreme Court sided with Bittner, saying that fair notice hadn’t been given, specifically to the point that it would demand individual fines for each undisclosed bank account. Ripple is similarly arguing that fair notice was not adequately provided. 

In this week’s filing, the SEC said that based on other, long standing Supreme Court precedents, namely those established in Upton v. SEC, which established the Howey Test, have given Ripple ample time to adhere to securities laws. 

Ripple’s legal team did not return Blockworks’ request for comment.


Get the news in your inbox. Explore Blockworks newsletters:

Tags

Decoding crypto and the markets. Daily, with Byron Gilliam.

Upcoming Events

Old Billingsgate

Mon - Wed, October 13 - 15, 2025

Blockworks’ Digital Asset Summit (DAS) will feature conversations between the builders, allocators, and legislators who will shape the trajectory of the digital asset ecosystem in the US and abroad.

recent research

Research Report Templates.png

Research

Content Delivery Networks (CDNs) represent low-hanging fruit in a massive market ripe for Web3-driven disruption. The global CDN market was valued at ~$28B in 2024, and is projected to surpass $140B by 2034, (18.75% CAGR) underscoring the immense demand for efficient content delivery.

article-image

The next step in Blockworks’ evolution into a data powerhouse increases customizability and autonomy over their high quality charts and data

by Westie /
article-image

Sponsored

With early interest from an initial cohort of brands including Metaplex, Story Protocol, and Pipe Network, Shelby offers decentralized, cloud-speed storage for streaming, AI, and real-time content

article-image

The $135 million raise shows that TradFi giants are serious about crypto adoption

article-image

The banking system still processes payments like it’s 1975. Crypto might have a fix.

article-image

Fiserv’s launch follows Senate passage of the GENIUS Act for stablecoin regulation.

article-image

Bitcoin is emerging as “the new standard for long-term corporate resilience,” Swan Bitcoin CIO says