Coin Center raises legal questions over Tornado Cash co-founders’ indictment

Peter Van Valkenburgh argues that the indictment against Tornado Cash contradicts FinCEN guidelines


VideoFlow/Shutterstock, modified by Blockworks


Coin Center is contesting the latest indictments against Tornado Cash.

Peter Van Valkenburgh, research director at the non-profit blockchain advocacy group, stated that the indictment’s limited facts don’t clearly indicate any legal violations of the relevant law.

The US Justice Department charged the co-founders of Tornado Cash with money laundering and sanctions violations on Wednesday. 

Additionally, co-founder Roman Semenov was placed on the Office of Foreign Assets Control’s (OFAC) list of specially designated nationals. Roman Storm, Semenov’s business associate, was also implicated. Both are accused of laundering over $1 billion in illicit funds via their crypto mixing service.

Valkenburgh argued in a Wednesday blog that the allegations in the indictment seem to contradict guidelines set by the US Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN).

Read more: DOJ arrests Tornado Cash co-founder Roman Storm, OFAC sanctions Roman Semenov

He stated that Tornado Cash merely supplies the software for money transmission, rather than transmitting money itself.

He further pointed out that the indictment lacks factual evidence to demonstrate that the accused were involved in activities that would legally be considered money transmission.

Valkenburgh cited FinCEN’s interpretation of the relevant rule under the US Bank Secrecy Act, which states that a provider of anonymizing software is not considered a “money transmitter.”

“The indictment provides various factual allegations describing the activities the defendants performed, but all of those facts point to the defendants fitting squarely within FinCEN’s guidance on anonymizing software providers rather than them being money transmitters,” the research director wrote.

He also stated that while the government accuses the defendants of promoting Tornado Cash, earning profits from a governance token and creating various features of the tool, none of these actions constitute the receipt and transfer of money.

In 2022, OFAC imposed sanctions on Tornado Cash, alleging that the platform enabled hackers to launder $7 billion in cryptocurrency. They specifically targeted 45 Ethereum wallet addresses.

In response, Coin Center filed a lawsuit against the US Treasury, claiming that the sanctions imposed on Tornado Cash unlawfully penalize Americans seeking to safeguard their privacy when utilizing their own digital assets.

The US federal court recently upheld sanctions against the crypto mixing service, dismissing a separate Coinbase-backed lawsuit. The ruling has wider implications, impacting individuals who seek to use privacy-focused protocols for lawful purposes.

Don’t miss the next big story – join our free daily newsletter.


Upcoming Events

MON - WED, MARCH 18 - 20, 2024

Digital Asset Summit (DAS) is returning March 2024. What you can expect: And more! Don’t miss out on the opportunity to be in the room when the future of crypto is decided. Join us and help shape the future of our […]

recent research

Research report - cover graphics-2.jpg


Base has doubled-down on its commitment to the Superchain vision, has shown early signs of success with nearly $400M in TVL, and has become home to novel dapps such as which has seen significant traction.


The bitcoin halving slated for April 2024 — an event expected to spur upward price action for BTC — could be a boon for Block’s stock price, analysts say


Seed Club founder Jess Sloss is excited to “open the doors and let other people see what we’ve been seeing for the last few months”


Blockchain is a “natural fit” in games based on open economies and user-generated content, says Wyatt


Their current stance is a half-baked attempt that could stifle innovation and burden an emerging industry


Maker’s DeFi-focused “subDAO” passed a proposal activating a lending market for DAI on the Gnosis Chain


Certain creditors could be repaid sooner, with one hedge fund exec telling Blockworks it expects a payout by the end of the year