Ethereum transactions frozen for 12 seconds

The 12-second ‘censorship’ proof of concept sparked discussions on one of Ethereum’s core principles

article-image

Volodymyr_Shtun/Shutterstock modified by Blockworks

share

A recently organized team of researchers, the ​​Special Mechanisms Group (SMG), demonstrated Thursday how to take advantage of a facet of the proposer-builder separation market to force through an Ethereum block containing just one transaction: theirs.

Proposer-builder separation (PBS) is intended to increase censorship-resistance by separating the roles of block builders and block proposers in the more-or-less unceasing Ethereum blockchain. But the group found a way to use the feature to make a very public point.

Loading Tweet..

The block’s lone transaction embedded a URL to a presentation and research paper on SMG’s website, describing the problem and proposing potential ways to address it.

Reactions were decidedly mixed.

Ryan Berckmans, a former software engineer at Augur, was among many who pointed out that Ethereum’s gas fee market would make it difficult to delay transactions using this method for long, but noted it did reveal certain problems in the way some applications on Ethereum calculate fees needed to get transactions included in a block.

“The interesting thing about the quoted method is that to censor all transactions for one block, they only have to outbid priority fees.”

Loading Tweet..

Why does it matter?

Ethereum is designed to be “credibly neutral,” and therefore any time user transactions can be prevented from being included in a block, it’s cause for alarm.

(Technically, post-Merge they’re called “slots,” but the terms are interchangeable.)

But most people conceptualize “censorship” as preventing a transaction permanently, not merely delaying it for a short time. It’s also not a new problem.

Loading Tweet..

The SMG group disagrees.

“When bidders in an auction, or agents in a financial system can censor their competition, the efficiency of these systems erodes,” they tweeted. “In other words, censorship-resistance is about more than just ensuring a transaction gets on-chain ‘eventually.’ It needs to be fast.”

SMG’s head of research and one of the paper’s authors, Max Resnick, told Blockworks, “we are more worried about 12 seconds being enough time to cause a problem than 10 mins,” although he said the critics overestimate the cost of increasing the delay period further.

Even on a short timeframe, however, “there are a lot of useful mechanisms (like auctions) that we can’t build on chain because it would be easy for participants to censor their competition’s bids,” Resnick said.

Some use cases that don’t tolerate inclusion delays could migrate to layer-2s, but not all, he said.

“Let’s use enshrined PBS as an example, because that is an auction that we want to run on-chain and can’t really be run on a rollup.”

Enshrined PBS, or ePBS, would implement PBS at the protocol level — the Ethereum mainnet consensus layer — but how to do this is an active research topic and remains a relatively distant prospect.

“This is particularly relevant in auctions, but also applies to fraud proofs and oracle updates to a lesser extent,” Resnick said.

In other words, this case implies that it may be hard to reduce the window for producing a fraud proof in optimistic rollups, although it does not impact ZK rollups.

“I think if we could make the base chain more censorship resistant, then optimistic rollups would have better user experience,” Resnick said.


Get the news in your inbox. Explore Blockworks newsletters:

Tags

Upcoming Events

Old Billingsgate

Mon - Wed, October 13 - 15, 2025

Blockworks’ Digital Asset Summit (DAS) will feature conversations between the builders, allocators, and legislators who will shape the trajectory of the digital asset ecosystem in the US and abroad.

Industry City | Brooklyn, NY

TUES - THURS, JUNE 24 - 26, 2025

Permissionless IV serves as the definitive gathering for crypto’s technical founders, developers, and builders to come together and create the future.If you’re ready to shape the future of crypto, Permissionless IV is where it happens.

Brooklyn, NY

SUN - MON, JUN. 22 - 23, 2025

Blockworks and Cracked Labs are teaming up for the third installment of the Permissionless Hackathon, happening June 22–23, 2025 in Brooklyn, NY. This is a 36-hour IRL builder sprint where developers, designers, and creatives ship real projects solving real problems across […]

recent research

Research Report Templates (1).jpg

Research

Jupiter has emerged as the undisputed liquidity backbone of Solana, commanding over 90% of spot DEX aggregation and 80% of perp trading volume. But behind the numbers lies a far more ambitious play: a cross-chain, vertically integrated super-app spanning swaps, synthetics, NFTs, memecoins, and launchpads. This report explores Jupiter’s rapid rise, the monetization upgrades reshaping its revenue profile, and the risks that could unwind its dominance, from token dilution to competition. With annualized revenues nearing $300M, the upside is undeniable, if it can navigate the turbulence.

article-image

Immutable has been building a game with Ubisoft that was slated to unveil in April. It may be a TCG.

article-image

Curve founder Michael Egorov is working on a new protocol designed to eliminate impermanent loss, rethink token emissions, and capture BTC-native yield

article-image

Mining outfits have gone bust in the wake of prior halvings. Not so this time around.

article-image

Zora’s announcement that its token is for “fun only” sparked a debate about the need for such tokens

article-image

In recent weeks, Helium has hit new all-time highs while passing major protocol milestones

article-image

Financial advisers in a January survey said equity ETFs were their top choice for gaining crypto exposure in 2025