Court largely rules against Coinbase’s dismissal efforts in SEC case

Judge Failla found that Coinbase didn’t operate as an unregistered broker in offering its wallet service

article-image

sdx15/Shutterstock modified by Blockworks

share

The Securities and Exchange Commission and crypto exchange Coinbase each scored partial wins in a Wednesday morning court ruling amid their ongoing legal fight.

Judge Katherine Polk Failla denied most of Coinbase’s efforts to dismiss the SEC’s lawsuit. Specifically, Failla said that the SEC “sufficiently pleaded” that Coinbase operates as a clearing agency, broker and exchange under the federal laws. 

The court also found that the exchange’s staking program “engages in the unregistered offer and sale of securities.”

“The Court further finds that the SEC has sufficiently pleaded control person liability for CGI under the Exchange Act,” the filing Wednesday said.

However, Coinbase notched a win in its motion. The court granted Coinbase’s claims about its wallet service. The SEC previously argued that Coinbase acts as an unregistered broker when offering its wallet service. 

“The factual allegations concerning Wallet are insufficient to support the plausible inference that Coinbase ‘engaged in the business of effecting transactions in securities for the account of others’ through its Wallet application,” Failla wrote.

But, on the grounds of staking, Judge Failla said that the SEC “plausibly alleged” that Coinbase violated parts of the Securities Act by not registering with the SEC for the program. She further added that this is due to staking customers having a reasonable expectation of profit due to “Coinbase’s managerial efforts,” which falls under Howey.

Transactions made with crypto on a secondary market are not “categorically excluded” from being investment contracts, Failla said in her opinion. 

“An investor selecting an investment opportunity in either setting is attracted by the promises and offers made by issuers to the investing public,” she wrote.

The court also ruled that the SEC’s enforcement action doesn’t fall under the major questions doctrine, an argument Coinbase previously made. 

“Perhaps more importantly, the SEC is asserting neither a ‘transformative expansion in its regulatory authority,’ nor a ‘highly consequential power beyond what Congress could reasonably be understood to have granted’ it,” Failla wrote.

Failla ordered both sides to prepare a proposed case management plan next month ahead of an expected trial. 

Coinbase’s chief legal officer Paul Grewal said that the team “were prepared” for the denial in a post on X. 

“Looking ahead, we remain confident in our legal arguments, we look forward to proving we’re right, we are eager for the opportunity to take discovery from the SEC for the first time, and we appreciate the Court’s continued consideration of our case,” he added.

“We’re pleased that yet another court has confirmed that, while the term ‘crypto’ may be relatively new, the framework that courts have used to identify securities for nearly 80 years still applies. It’s the economic realities of a transaction, not the labels, that determine whether a particular offering constitutes a security,” an SEC spokesperson told Blockworks. 

Updated March 27, 2024 at 1:40 pm ET: Added comment from the SEC.

Updated March 27, 2024 at 12:09 pm ET: Added comment from Coinbase.


Get the news in your inbox. Explore Blockworks newsletters:

Tags

Upcoming Events

Old Billingsgate

Mon - Wed, October 13 - 15, 2025

Blockworks’ Digital Asset Summit (DAS) will feature conversations between the builders, allocators, and legislators who will shape the trajectory of the digital asset ecosystem in the US and abroad.

Industry City | Brooklyn, NY

TUES - THURS, JUNE 24 - 26, 2025

Permissionless IV serves as the definitive gathering for crypto’s technical founders, developers, and builders to come together and create the future.If you’re ready to shape the future of crypto, Permissionless IV is where it happens.

Brooklyn, NY

SUN - MON, JUN. 22 - 23, 2025

Blockworks and Cracked Labs are teaming up for the third installment of the Permissionless Hackathon, happening June 22–23, 2025 in Brooklyn, NY. This is a 36-hour IRL builder sprint where developers, designers, and creatives ship real projects solving real problems across […]

recent research

Featured.png

Research

Helium stands at a pivotal moment in its evolution as a decentralized wireless network, balancing rapid growth, economic restructuring, and global expansion. With accelerated growth in domestic DAUs and Hotspots supporting its network, Helium is leveraging strategic partnerships and innovative proposals to scale internationally. The recent implementation of HIP 138, “Return to HNT,” has unified its token economy under HNT, simplifying participation and strengthening liquidity, while HIP 139’s phase-out of CBRS refocuses efforts on scalable Wi-Fi offload. Meanwhile, governance shifts under HIP 141 raise questions about centralization as Nova Labs consolidates control over the roadmap.

article-image

The DeFi Education Fund has ideas on how the crypto-friendly SEC can bring Commissioner Peirce’s vision to life

article-image

“Be prepared to do more with less,” Framework Ventures’ Michael Anderson said

article-image

Q1 may have been “frustrating,” but things are looking brighter for Q2

article-image

Tokens worth 20% of the current supply of the TRUMP memecoin launched by the president are set to be unlocked tomorrow

article-image

A crypto-industry lawsuit is “moot” now that Joint Resolution 25 has been signed into law

article-image

Fed Chair Powell assured markets that the labor market is in “good place,” dependent on price stability