Should the Fed cut 50bps in September?

We’re beginning to price in the chance of not just a 25 basis point cut, but a 50 bps one

share


This is a segment from the Forward Guidance newsletter. To read full editions, subscribe.


It’s amazing how quickly things can change in one week.

It feels like only yesterday that the Fed appeared unlikely to cut rates at all in September. Now, we’re beginning to price in the chance of not just a 25 basis point cut, but a 50 bps one!

In a Tuesday Fox Business interview, Treasury Secretary Bessent added fuel to the speculation by saying “the real thing now to think about is: Should we get a 50 basis point rate cut in September?”

I’m old enough to remember when Bessent said he wouldn’t comment on future monetary policy decisions. But here we are. 

So, should the Fed cut 50 bps in September? Let’s look at both sides of the argument. 

No cuts

Although this month’s CPI print was pretty tame and consensus, there are some underlying inflation pressures building. 

Core goods, one of the biggest drivers of the disinflation story over the last couple years, is now beginning to accelerate higher, largely driven by tariffs:

Despite a pretty nasty jobs report last week, forward-looking estimates point to a labor market that is beginning to reaccelerate again. 

In the most recent business headcount surveys, the amount of businesses that planned on meaningfully increasing headcount in the next year bounced higher:

Looking at Visa’s US spending momentum index, the consumer appears pretty resilient in the face of tariffs and their spending habits are looking like they’re beginning to tick higher:

Based on this confluence of data, I could make the argument that the economy is beginning to reaccelerate. If the Fed were to cut in September based on lagging data such as NFP, it could end up being a mistake that makes the bond market sell off like it did last year when the Fed did the same thing. 

Cut and go big

Consumption is the engine that drives the US economy. Ever since Q4 2024, it’s been meaningfully slowing. 

If purchasing power decreases due to the continued implementation of tariffs, we could well see further weakening in consumer spending that could quite quickly look recessionary.

Meanwhile, tariff collections continue to surge higher — and someone needs to foot that bill:

If companies pass on the tariffs to the consumer, those higher prices will eventually hurt aggregate demand since that additional price increase means that money cannot be spent elsewhere. Without an offset, this is negative for growth. 

If companies absorb the price hikes, it will squeeze their corporate profit margins, which will also lower economic output. Either way, it’s negative for the growth outlook. 

Finally, with a labor market that continues to surprise to the downside with downward revisions that continue to tick lower pro-cyclically, some sort of insurance rate cut could make sense here.

Putting it all together, I can make the case for a pause as much as I can make a case for substantial cuts. 

It’s no wonder the FOMC, on the question of where to go from here, is the most divided it’s been in decades.


Get the news in your inbox. Explore Blockworks newsletters:

Tags

Decoding crypto and the markets. Daily, with Byron Gilliam.

Upcoming Events

Old Billingsgate

Mon - Wed, October 13 - 15, 2025

Blockworks’ Digital Asset Summit (DAS) will feature conversations between the builders, allocators, and legislators who will shape the trajectory of the digital asset ecosystem in the US and abroad.

recent research

Research Report Templates (1).png

Research

Aave’s revenues have doubled from April lows and are fast approaching all-time highs. With 35% of borrow interest coming from ETH and 55% from stablecoins, Aave is emerging as a powerful proxy as an ETH and stablecoin beta. As looping strategies accelerate growth and Horizon positions the protocol to ride the RWA wave, Aave is shaping up as one of DeFi’s most compelling multi-narrative plays.

article-image

Solana saw $78 million in REV for August

article-image

Lit Protocol’s Vincent is shifting agentic finance from toy demos to production rails

article-image

The new system aims to unify Europe’s fragmented tokenized asset settlement and cut cross-border costs

by Blockworks /
article-image

Tron slashed fees by 60% as Plasma looms, threatening its USDT moat

article-image

The acquisition adds evaluation-based funding to Kraken Pro, giving traders access to capital on performance

by Blockworks /
article-image

The deal merges real-time pricing data with on-chain credit ratings, aiming to boost institutional adoption of decentralized finance

by Blockworks /