Public-key birthday: ‘Cypherpunk sacred text’ turns 49 today

This is a segment from the Supply Shock newsletter. To read full editions, subscribe.

---

It took nearly seven centuries for a cryptography breakthrough to sunset the Caesar cipher that was big in the first century BC.

Caesar ciphers simply shifted letters up or down in the alphabet by a fixed number of positions. Starting in the year 800, Arab polymath al-Kindi began working on what’s known as frequency analysis — a type of systematic pattern recognition that would result in reverse-engineering shift cipher encryption, like the Caesar.

By the 16th-century Renaissance, solving Caesar ciphers was so easy that they were considered children’s puzzles.

So it was until two cryptographers, Italian Giovan Battista Bellaso and French Blaise de Vigenère, discovered and popularized the so-called Vigenère cipher, which incorporated multiple cipher alphabets derived from a single keyword.

The Vigenère cipher was a revolution in information privacy. The poly-alphabetic method was believed unbreakable and even named the “indecipherable cipher.” 

Three hundred years would pass before, in the mid-19th century, two others independently cracked the system. 

Charles Babbage, a revered grandfather of computer science, and military man Friedrich Kasiski, unknown to each other, had separately rendered Vigenères entirely obsolete, even before the arrival of computers.

So, that makes for a 700-year gap between Caesar and al-Kindi, and a 300-year gap between Bellaso-Vigenère and Babbage-Kasiski.

A cypherpunk breakthrough

On this exact day in 1976 — 49 years ago and more than a century after Babbage and Kasiski cracked Vigenère — a pair of American academics presented their own revolution: the concept of public key cryptography, which today underpins Bitcoin and most modern communication technologies.

Building off the novel work of computer scientist Ralph Merkle, the duo of Richard Diffie and Martin Hellman had devised a way to achieve what was, once again, considered theoretically impossible: enabling secure communication without a secret key shared between the two parties.

The method was outlined in their paper, New Directions in Cryptography, which WIRED would later describe as “a cypherpunk sacred text.”

“We stand today on the brink of a revolution in cryptography,” Diffie and Hellman wrote. “The development of cheap digital hardware has freed it from the design limitations of mechanical computing and brought the cost of high grade cryptographic devices down to where they can be used in such commercial applications as remote cash dispensers and computer terminals.”

“… At the same time, theoretical developments in information theory and computer science show promise of providing provably secure cryptosystems, changing this ancient art into a science.”

Diffie-Hellman’s paper would be adapted into RSA encryption within two years, itself a touchy cornerstone of the Crypto Wars that directly followed. 

Amazingly, as WIRED documented, another cryptographer, British intelligence officer James Ellis, had proposed a public-key system years before the Diffie-Hellman paper. But Ellis’ work was never permitted to see the light of day, a factoid that makes the conclusion of Diffie and Hellman’s foundational work so much more poignant: 

“We hope this will inspire others to work in this fascinating area in which participation has been discouraged in the recent past by a nearly total government monopoly.” 

And while specific or weak forms of public-key encryption have been broken over the years, it remains unbroken at a theoretical level.

Now, (almost) half a century on from cryptography’s last great breakthrough, all eyes are on the arrival of practical quantum computing — whenever that may be.

---

Get the news in your inbox. Explore Blockworks newsletters:

• The Breakdown: Decoding crypto and the markets. Daily.
• 0xResearch: Alpha in your inbox. Think like an analyst.