SEC in hot water after Ripple ruling, former agency attorney says

Although other federal district judges are not obligated to follow Judge Torres’ ruling, the opinion should still hold weight, Christian Schultz said

article-image

CryptoFX/Shutterstock modified by Blockworks

share

According to Christian Schultz, a former assistant chief litigation counsel at the SEC’s enforcement division, the recent partial judgment in the SEC’s case against Ripple has the potential to disrupt the agency’s other ongoing legal proceedings, despite being a district court ruling.

Judge Analisa Torres passed down a partial summary judgment last week, siding in part with the SEC with regards to the institutional sale of XRP tokens and in part with Ripple regarding programmatic sales. The case will proceed to trial, Torres ruled, but industry experts are still largely looking at the decision as a major triumph for Ripple and other token issuers. 

“There’s no way to look at the Ripple decision as anything but a win for the crypto industry,” Schultz said. “XRP is not a security and the company’s and executives’ transactions in XRP on the secondary market do not violate the securities laws.”

Read more: Crypto industry is ‘afraid to celebrate’ Ripple’s ‘giant win’ over the SEC

Although other federal district judges are not obligated to follow Torres’ ruling, the opinion should still hold weight, said Schultz, who now serves as a partner at Washington, DC-based Arnold and Porter. 

“That being said, it is a thoughtful decision from a well-respected jurist that other judges will find persuasive,” Schultz said. “That could spell problems for the SEC in other pending litigation, particularly those that are focused primarily if not exclusively on secondary market activity.”

The summary judgment issued this month was a partial ruling and not a full judgment. There are a number of issues still left to be dealt with at trial, including what, if any, penalty Ripple must face for its initial institutional sales of XRP, which the court has deemed a security.

The final numbers will take awhile to determine, Schultz said, but, in theory, Ripple could be ordered to pay disgorgement from the institutional sales, meaning the company would have to hand over any profits made from the sales, plus prejudgment interest. Ripple may also have to pay civil penalties. 

The SEC could still appeal the partial judgment ruling, but Torres’ claim that programmatic sales are not securities complicates other charges in the case, Schultz said. In its initial complaint, the SEC charged Ripple’s founder and former CEO Christian Larsen and former chief operating officer and current CEO Brad Garlinghouse with aiding and abetting securities laws violations. Those allegations in part rest on the assumption that XRP is a security. 

“The SEC could take a cue from Judge Torres’ ruling denying summary judgment on the aiding and abetting claims against the executives, which demonstrates the evidentiary weakness in those claims and the reasons a jury could rule in the executives’ favor at trial, and choose not to pursue those claims any further so it can appeal the arguments that it otherwise lost against Ripple and the executives,” Schultz said.


Get the news in your inbox. Explore Blockworks newsletters:

Tags

Decoding crypto and the markets. Daily, with Byron Gilliam.

Upcoming Events

Old Billingsgate

Mon - Wed, October 13 - 15, 2025

Blockworks’ Digital Asset Summit (DAS) will feature conversations between the builders, allocators, and legislators who will shape the trajectory of the digital asset ecosystem in the US and abroad.

recent research

Research Report Templates (3).png

Research

Pear Protocol has proven its market fit through its pair-trading infrastructure, sustaining consistent trading activity despite recent headwinds. Its strategic pivot toward Hyperliquid integration represents a major growth catalyst amid industry consolidation. While short-term token unlocks present challenges, current valuations and liquidity conditions may offer compelling opportunities for investors.

article-image

The House embraces crypto — but keeps the fences up

article-image

The network got slower in June — and it wasn’t for tech-related reasons

article-image

After a jittery few months, recent economic data is hinting at a resilient economy that is beginning to re-accelerate

article-image

The stablecoin bill now heads to the president’s desk

article-image

The House on Thursday passed the CLARITY Act, a landmark cryptocurrency market structure bill

article-image

Interchain Labs will focus on sovereign L1s and institutional demand, abandoning plans for smart contracts on the Cosmos Hub