Former Bank of England Governor Throws Support Behind CBDCs

In a speech to the Bank of International Settlements, Mark Carney, the former governor of the Bank of England and the Bank of Canada argued that the further integration of stablecoins into the global economy would give big tech too much power in the economy and would be difficult to unwind.

article-image

Mark Carney

share

key takeaways

  • In a speech at the Bank of International Settlements, Mark Carney argued for CBDCs to keep control of money away from big tech.
  • In contrast, Federal Reserve Vice Chair Randal Quarles argued that CBDCs are too risky and have unclear benefits at the moment.

Two of the most prominent names in central banking have very different opinions on central bank digital currencies (CBDCs) and stablecoins. 

In a speech to the Bank of International Settlements, Mark Carney, the former governor of the Bank of England and the Bank of Canada argued that the further integration of stablecoins into the global economy would give big tech too much power in the economy and would be difficult to unwind. 

“We should be wary of path dependence and locking in existing advantages of tech companies via the payments system. There are powerful network effects in both social networks and money. If combined, these could be mutually reinforcing. Convenience once established may be hard to unwind in the Uberisation of money,” he said. 

Carney also said that integrating stablecoins into the global economy can pose significant structural risks. The industry should be heavily regulated with strong capital and liquidity requirements in addition to consumer protection rules that allow for stablecoin holders to be paid in fiat currency on demand, he added.

“There’s been two systemic crises in money funds in little more than a decade,” said Carney. “In baseball, it’s three strikes and you’re out. In cricket, it’s only the equivalent of one. For systemic payment systems, one is too many.” 

Carney also argued that if stablecoins become heavily regulated, the difference between them and CBDCs would begin to blur. “If that means – as it must – very rigorous oversight and rules for private stablecoins, what would then differentiate them from CBDCs?” he asked.

Federal Reserve Vice Chair Randal Quarles, in contrast, believes that the benefits of CBDCs aren’t clear enough to warrant the investment and the “considerable challenges for the structure of our banking system” currently aren’t worth the trouble. He also pointed out that the tools to counter money laundering for a CBDC would pose significant challenges to user privacy. 

“An arrangement where the Federal Reserve replaces commercial banks as the dominant provider of money to the general public could constrict the availability of credit, fundamentally alter the economy, and expose the public to a host of unanticipated, and undesirable, consequences, he said. 

Quarles said that “we do not need to fear stablecoins,” and, if anything, the popularity of US-dollar denominated stablecoins only reinforces the USD’s hegemony in global finance. 

Looking to China

The People’s Bank of China’s CBDC project, the eCNY, is the furthest along of all the efforts and while Beijing has said that it doesn’t intend for its CBDC to challenge the US dollar, other nations are watching closely.  

“If it launches a CBDC, China will be armed with huge social infrastructure,” former Bank of Japan governor Toshihide Endo said in an interview with Reuters. “It would be a move hard to ignore for other nations. Japan and other advanced nations will face the tough question of how quickly they should follow.”

A prototype of a US CBDC, developed by the Boston Fed and MIT, is expected to be unveiled in July along with a white paper that outlines the Fed’s position on the topic.  

Tags

Decoding crypto and the markets. Daily, with Byron Gilliam.

Upcoming Events

Old Billingsgate

Mon - Wed, October 13 - 15, 2025

Blockworks’ Digital Asset Summit (DAS) will feature conversations between the builders, allocators, and legislators who will shape the trajectory of the digital asset ecosystem in the US and abroad.

recent research

Research Report Templates.png

Research

Content Delivery Networks (CDNs) represent low-hanging fruit in a massive market ripe for Web3-driven disruption. The global CDN market was valued at ~$28B in 2024, and is projected to surpass $140B by 2034, (18.75% CAGR) underscoring the immense demand for efficient content delivery.

article-image

Sponsored

Injective is not waiting for the future of finance. It is bringing it directly to us, today.

article-image

Bitcoin has been bullish for nearly 1,000 days

article-image

Robinhood announced that it’s building an L2 and also plans to launch staking for US users

article-image

“We’re not really doing anything controversial,” said co-founder Zak Folkman at Permissionless last week

article-image

Why equities are more stable than in past decades, plus advice from Peter Lynch

article-image

As Permissionless speakers talk on-chain RWA potential, tokenized stock platform Dinari secures FINRA broker-dealer approval