NFT Projects Beware: Top Shots Class Action Could Set Precedent

A judge says it is plausible Top Shot Moments are securities, and the decision could change the entire NFT industry

article-image

NBA Top Shot modified by Blockworks

share

Dapper Labs may not get its way in the class action lawsuit against its Top Shot NFTs, and other projects should be on notice, attorneys say. 

Counsel from Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher and Flom LLP said that the court’s decision last week to allow the class action, alleging Top Shot moments are securities, to move forward foreshadows how NFTs may be treated in the future. 

US District Judge Victor Marreo determined the plaintiff’s argument — that Dapper Lab’s NBA Top Show Moments passes the Howey Test —- is plausible. But ruling against dismissal does not in and of itself signify any ruling, attorneys said. 

The Howey Test has four main pillars to determine whether an asset is a security: 

  • Has money been invested? 
  • Is it a common enterprise? 
  • Is there a reasonable expectation of profit?
  • Is the profit derived from the efforts of others?

There was an undisputed investment of money, Dapper Labs and the plaintiffs agree, and, Marreo said in the filing, it could be conceived that there was a pooling of funds as Moments sales created revenue and supported the Flow blockchain, which has its own native token, FLOW.

As for reasonable expectation of profits, it is feasible that Moments values were determined by Dapper Labs’ ability to turn a profit, Marreo said.

A key factor in the case is going to come down to Dapper Lab’s sole control over the marketplace where Moments were bought and sold, giving Dapper the ability to “significantly, if not entirely, dictate[d] Moments’ use and value.”

“This aspect of the court’s ruling highlights the potential regulatory risks of a ‘walled garden’ business model where the NFT issuer creates its own marketplace that serves as the only place for buyers and sellers to trade,” attorneys wrote in a contributed piece to Columbia Law School’s blog. 

The plaintiffs, in their allegations, argued Moments’ royalty structure makes them a horizontal commonality, meaning there was a “pooling of funds tied to the success of the overall venture.” Plaintiffs also said Dapper is operating a vertical commonality because it collects a percentage on each sale. The court agreed there was adequate evidence to the horizontal commonality argument, but not the vertical commonality allegations. 

“The court held that the presence of seller royalties not directionally linked to an NFT holder’s profits or losses is insufficient, by itself, to establish vertical commonality between the promoter and purchasers — a ruling that could have broader ramifications given the near-ubiquity of royalties in the NFT market,” the attorneys wrote. 

There is legal precedent to accept both types of commonalities as evidence an asset is a security, attorneys at Winston and Strawn noted

It is unclear whether the case will proceed to trial or if a settlement may be reached. A precedent could be set.


Get the news in your inbox. Explore Blockworks newsletters:

Tags

Decoding crypto and the markets. Daily, with Byron Gilliam.

Upcoming Events

Old Billingsgate

Mon - Wed, October 13 - 15, 2025

Blockworks’ Digital Asset Summit (DAS) will feature conversations between the builders, allocators, and legislators who will shape the trajectory of the digital asset ecosystem in the US and abroad.

recent research

Research Report Templates (20).png

Research

The dynamic between Ethena, Pendle and Aave exhibits a mutually-beneficial relationship, where the offerings of each business grows the top lines of every party in this exchange. Pendle sits at the intersection of YBA issuers (Ethena) and money markets (Aave), demonstrating heightened utilization rates of YBAs, where the PTs then exhibit profound utilization as collateral. YBA issuers see Pendle as a premier go-to-market venue, often underwriting incentives for liquidity on the market and solving for Pendle’s supply side, while money markets view PTs as attractive collateral types to lend against, solving for Pendle’s demand side. PTs represent a highly profitable collateral listing for Aave, with depositors maxing out the available borrow capacity. Pendle’s recent launch of Boros may now present the most material growth vector beyond what is currently exhibited on V2 markets, offering the ability to price yield, spreads, and duration risk across various points in time out into the future.

article-image

If fear moves markets, there could be more all-time highs to come

article-image

Ether-focused BitMine Immersion saw its daily trading volumes surge this week

article-image

From Ronin’s classic L2 pivot to Taiko’s based rollup and Puffer’s ultra-low-latency appchain testnet, Ethereum-aligned architectures are multiplying

article-image

The Gemini Wallet and Onchain hub are great for total beginners, but have a lot of room to grow

article-image

Airlines defend their rewards moat, Binance courts favor over breakfast, DAT fees pile up and systematic thinking