RWAs shouldn’t be for everyone

It’s not reasonable to expect someone who trades stocks on Robinhood to also have the ability to appropriately discern their risk with many RWAs 

OPINION
article-image

Artwork by Crystal Le

share

Real-world assets has become a strong narrative in the Web3 space over the past year. As interest rates have risen while DeFi yields have dropped (and exploits have impacted some blue-chip protocols), more and more players are emerging with offers of tokenized Treasurys, illiquid assets and credit products for new sources of yield. 

The question is, is access alone a benefit?

While some will argue that access to these asset classes should be universal, I disagree. 

There is a reason why complex credit products are currently only sold to investors who have the means and ability to understand and handle the risks. It’s not reasonable to expect someone who trades stocks on Robinhood to also have the ability to appropriately discern their risk when buying a private debt security. These are deals done by professionals for professionals — allowing retail investors access will surely devolve into a situation where smart money dumps on those less sophisticated.

The drive toward bringing RWA’s on chain should strike a balance between a need for access and the reasonable expectation that investors understand the risks. 

And — in balancing these guiding principles with the products investors need — I believe the next RWA opportunity is in foreign exchange.

I’m not suggesting non-dollar stablecoins. These exist in abundance and yet have not reached scale, mostly due to fixed banking hours causing liquidity gaps and dislocations between the tokenized version and the real-world version. 

Instead, I suggest the next RWA opportunity is in tokenized FX forwards. 

As the US Federal Reserve has embarked on the fastest hiking cycle in history, global central banks have also been forced to raise rates. Specifically in emerging market countries, rates have moved exponentially to protect their economies from importing inflation from the US. Holding non-dollar currencies in token form becomes an even bigger challenge without a way to earn that country’s risk-free yield.

Read more from our opinion section: How RWAs robbed 2023 of its liquidity

While some emerging and developed market currencies have been unable to keep up with the US dollar, plenty of countries have and are still paying high interest rates. 

Brazil is a great example. BRL/USD is currently in the middle of the range over the past five years, and the risk-free rate is just over 11%. For a nonfinancial professional to get exposure to BRL is tricky, and it’s even harder to get exposure to local interest rates. Creating an RWA that gives offshore clients access to the currency and yield is a game changer. It provides access to investors who want to invest in emerging market countries, but would otherwise be unable to do so.

Therein lies the opportunity. A product that offers investors access to non-dollar currencies and pays those currencies risk-free yield. Said another way, the product is a tokenized FX forward. This allows the buyer access to other countries’ high-interest rates and their risk/reward vs. the US dollar. And, unlike tokenized private credit products, there is no information asymmetry as all FX information is publicly available, leaving retail with as fair a chance as institutional capital. Tokenized FX forwards would become a new asset class in the crypto ecosystem. 

Read more from our opinion section: Stop tokenizing everything

Considering the risk-free yield as the currency’s staking rate, we can do a comparative risk-reward analysis vs. USD stablecoins and yield-generating cryptocurrencies. 

Tokenized FX forwards would sit between those risk categories with different return profiles. Tokenized FX forwards and PoS tokens both pay a yield, while stablecoins do not. While every currency and country differ, you will find some currencies, especially in Latin America, where the nominal interest rate is much higher than staking yields on top 20 tokens like SOL, DOT and ADA. Furthermore, the downside risk vs. the USD is much lower in FX forwards than in cryptocurrencies.

Using Brazil again as an example, BRL can drop 20% vs. the USD in a highly adverse scenario, while most cryptocurrencies have experienced an 80%+ loss during bear markets. Meanwhile, BRL risk free yields are close to 11%, while SOL, ADA and even ETH are low single digits. This product has a lower risk/reward profile than most cryptocurrencies, while delivering a much higher yield. 

The major downside of BRL and other major FX forwards compared to crypto is that the ability to outperform the dollar is limited. In the case of BRL, an extreme upside scenario would only see BRL beat the US dollar by 20%. 

For these reasons, I see tokenized FX forwards as a risk profile that sits in between USD stablecoins and cryptocurrencies.

Products that represent the short-term interest rates of non-US countries have both a market fit and provide access to people who can adequately assess the risk. Tokenized FX forwards are a natural next step in the tokenized RWA movement: they give access to a new form of cryptocurrency while providing a better defensive opportunity in bear markets. 

While other tokenization attempts have questionable utility, tokenized FX forwards offer a clear benefit and at the same time, actually move the world of on-chain money forward. 



Start your day with top crypto insights from David Canellis and Katherine Ross. Subscribe to the Empire newsletter.

Tags

Upcoming Events

Salt Lake City, UT

WED - FRI, OCTOBER 9 - 11, 2024

Pack your bags, anon — we’re heading west! Join us in the beautiful Salt Lake City for the third installment of Permissionless. Come for the alpha, stay for the fresh air. Permissionless III promises unforgettable panels, killer networking opportunities, and mountains […]

recent research

Screen Shot 2024-05-16 at 14.53.45.png

Research

Loss-versus-rebalancing (LVR) is arguably Ethereum DeFi’s biggest problem, and thus reducing LVR is fundamental to the success of Ethereum. This report dives into the world of LVR. We uncover its importance for AMM designers, discuss the two major mechanism design categories and various projects developing solutions, and offer a higher level perspective on the importance of AMMs in general.

article-image

Yesterday saw Congress’ upper chamber side with the House on a measure aimed at overturning SAB 121

article-image

Oklahoma’s new crypto bill will go into effect in November of this year

article-image

The deposits hit a $20 million cap in just 45 minutes

article-image

Twelve Democratic Senators voted in favor to pass the resolution Thursday

article-image

Pump.fun is “aware” that bonding curve contracts on Pump.fun were exploited, and has since paused trading

article-image

Some investment pros are mulling crypto allocations between 1% and 10% and seeking ex-BTC exposure for interested clients