How the SEC should categorize tokens: a16z Crypto
A16z Crypto lists seven buckets for tokens and recommendations for how to regulate them, in a filing submitted to the SEC
SEC Commissioner Hester Peirce | Permissionless II for Blockworks
This is a segment from the Empire newsletter. To read full editions, subscribe.
The SEC has some questions, and it seems a16z might have some answers.
In a 50-page filing, a16z addressed the newly-established Crypto Task Force, and some of the 50-page filing is filled with what you’d expect: how a16z Crypto thinks that the Howey Test should be utilized on a crypto company, their thoughts on what’s needed for a decentralized regulatory framework, and so on.
The biggest takeaway is simple: “When control is eliminated, the application of securities laws should be limited; when control is present, traditional (but modernized) approaches should be used.”
Makes sense, right? This approach is technologically neutral while also appeasing the fact that this industry needs some regulation (a point I think we can all finally agree on). Essentially, regulators should just need to get ahead of potential risks, rather than using merit as an assessment.
But the 50-page filing also included nuggets that don’t just apply to the SEC, and they’ve very kindly labeled categories of tokens for all of us.
These include: Network Tokens, Security Tokens, Company-Backed Tokens, Collectible Tokens, Arcade Tokens, Asset-Backed Tokens, and Memecoins.
Admittedly, there could be more, but the a16z Crypto team noted that these are the main types they’ve seen in the space. And, honestly, they check out in my book.
Now I know what some of you are thinking: We have a friendlier SEC. Is a filing explaining this to our very own Crypto Mother Hester Peirce really necessary? Yes. Mostly because crypto lacks the regulatory framework and legal precedents to protect the industry should non-crypto folks step back into the SEC.
Okay, so let’s go back to the token classifications. For network tokens, the suggestion is a “control-based decentralization framework guidance” for such tokens. The requirements would separate a network from the definition of a company, allowing profit expectations to network as opposed to a more centralized entity.
And, perhaps one of the most important tidbits: There should be guidance that properly lays out the conditions for liquidity for sales by insiders so that they differ from securities transactions.
“Doing so could help to restrict persons that exert control over a network token from participating in secondary markets of such a token and limit their ability to act on potential information asymmetries,” thereby solving a problem that’s popped up a few times in crypto.
Simply put, asset-backed tokens refer to stablecoins and wrapped tokens. And, well, as you saw yesterday, those are (hopefully) getting their own regulatory frameworks. A collectible token is another easy one, basically just something — like a piece of art, music, etc — that’d be protected under a safe harbor proposal.
Along those lines, an arcade token isn’t something you can use in an actual arcade (if you can find one that’s still open), but rather a form of currency within a game or online economy.
Company-backed tokens are linked to the company backing them (RIP FTT). And a security token is exactly what it sounds like: the digital form of a security, aka tokenization.
Memecoins are the outlier in this list, having already gotten some regulatory clarity from the SEC when the SEC said they have no intrinsic value. At least we have that one figured out!
We’re still in the wait-and-see era of crypto: We’re finally in a friendlier environment, but the rules haven’t quite been laid out yet. Once we get clarity, I can finally stop going on and on about being patient. Aren’t you excited?
Get the news in your inbox. Explore Blockworks newsletters:
- Blockworks Daily: Unpacking crypto and the markets.
- Empire: Crypto news and analysis to start your day.
- Forward Guidance: The intersection of crypto, macro and policy.
- 0xResearch: Alpha directly in your inbox.
- Lightspeed: All things Solana.
- The Drop: Apps, games, memes and more.
- Supply Shock: Bitcoin, bitcoin, bitcoin.
