SEC ‘discriminating’ against DeFi with proposed exchange definition: Blockchain Association

Last week, Paradigm pushed the SEC to ‘withdraw’ the proposal

article-image

AevanStock/Shutterstock modified by Blockworks

share

The Blockchain Association filed a second 14-page letter to the SEC’s proposed exchange definition change. 

The SEC is seeking to expand the definition of exchanges to include certain DeFi and crypto firms, including decentralized exchanges, or DEXs. 

In April, the SEC reopened the comment period following a press release stating that it wanted to expand the definition to cover DeFi. The comment period ends on Tuesday, June 13. 

“The reopening release reiterated the applicability of existing rules to platforms that trade crypto asset securities, including so-called ‘DeFi’ systems, and provides supplemental information and economic analysis for systems that would be included in the new, proposed exchange definition,” the SEC said in a statement.

The Blockchain Association wrote, “The SEC claims that its Proposal is ‘technology neutral,’ but in consistently ignoring the unique challenges that persons using or providing access to Decentralized Protocols face in complying with the Proposal, the SEC is effectively discriminating against this specific type of technology.

“The SEC is explicit that the burden will be greater for companies who rely on distributed ledger technology and has even acknowledged that some players will be forced out of business due to their inability to meet the newly imposed registration requirements.”

The Blockchain Association also brought up concerns about fair notice — which requires agencies to provide “fair warning” of conduct required or prohibited by regulated parties — in the proposal. 

“The rule change is vague and ambiguous, and the range of activities that may be captured within its scope are not yet fully fleshed out,” the association argued.

“Instead of crafting fit-for-purpose rules that recognize the unique nature of decentralized protocols and related entities, the SEC expands its jurisdiction beyond the limits originally set by Congress, while raising serious constitutional and APA concerns. This is the latest step in the Commission’s campaign to ban crypto in the U.S,” Kristin Smith, CEO of the Blockchain Association, said in a statement.

There’s also an argument to be made that the SEC’s proposal violates the Administrative Procedures Act (APA), which guides and governs how government agencies develop and issue regulations.

“There’s language in the proposal itself that basically says that the SEC believes that DeFi is already covered by the law. And they can’t put forth a new interpretation of current law that vastly expands what the current law says…without going through proper notice and comment procedures,” Marisa Coppel, policy counsel for the Blockchain Association, told Blockworks.

“So even though they’re going through that notice and comment now with this proposed rule, their statement in the proposal itself could be considered an APA violation and doesn’t put like those captured under this proposal unfair notice that the law already applies to them.” 

Other crypto firms including Paradigm, the DeFi Education Fund and even Republicans on Capitol Hill have responded to the proposed change with criticism

“The upshot of this technological reality is that holding DeFi protocols to the requirements of the regulatory regimes governing national securities exchanges and ATSs would result in their de facto expatriation from the United States. DeFi is rapidly gaining trading market share in crypto assets, especially after recent and high-profile fraud and compliance issues at leading centralized and intermediated non-U.S. crypto asset exchanges,” the DeFi Education Fund wrote.

Last week, Paradigm said, “We write to request that the Commission withdraw its proposed redefinition of ‘exchange’ and begin its consideration of how to adapt its regulations in the DeFi context anew — after rigorous economic analysis, genuine, broad engagement with the industry, and a close look at the limits of its statutory jurisdiction.”

Tavonia Evans, on behalf of the National Policy Network of Women of Color in Blockchain, wrote, “not all DEXs trade crypto for fiat currencies. Some DEXs primarily deal with the exchange of crypto assets, including stablecoins. The proposed rule does not provide clear guidelines on how it applies to DEXs that do not facilitate crypto-to-fiat transactions.”

Republicans from the House Financial Services Committee filed their own letter to push the SEC to withdraw the proposal. 

“Given the goals of this Proposed Rule, it is clear that Chair Gensler is using this proposal to push his own personal views regarding digital assets. Chair Gensler has previously made statements on his own behalf claiming that DeFi exchanges are essentially equivalent to traditional intermediaries in financial markets even if they call themselves something different,” they wrote on June 13.


Don’t miss the next big story – join our free daily newsletter.

Tags

Upcoming Events

Hilton Metropole | 225 Edgware Rd, London

MON - WED, MARCH 18 - 20, 2024

Crypto’s premier institutional conference returns to London in March 2024. The DAS: London Experience:  Attend expert-led panel discussions and fireside chats  Hear the latest developments regarding the crypto and digital asset regulatory environment directly from policymakers and experts   Grow your network […]

Salt Lake City, UT

WED - FRI, OCTOBER 9 - 11, 2024

Pack your bags, anon — we’re heading west! Join us in the beautiful Salt Lake City for the third installment of Permissionless. Come for the alpha, stay for the fresh air. Permissionless III promises unforgettable panels, killer networking opportunities, and mountains […]

recent research

logo.jpeg

Research

Akash is a general-purpose compute platform with GPUs, storage, LLM training or inference, and validator hosting through its two-sided marketplace.

article-image

The SEC could allow half a dozen or more such funds to launch at once, Ark Invest CEO says

article-image

2023 saw a decline in a16z crypto funding, but the behemoth VC firm teased what it’s excited for next year

article-image

“Iran Unchained” launched a new version of its grant platform to make donations to activists easier

article-image

The stablecoin marks the first time a regulated European bank has made a euro-pegged stablecoin available on a crypto exchange

article-image

Build it and they will come, perhaps, but making crypto easier to use is turning out to be just as important

article-image

Amid moves by Itau Unibanco and Nubank, the country could serve as “a proof of concept” for TradFi-crypto integrations, industry research exec says