SEC should ‘stop picking winners’: VanEck exec

Cboe filing on behalf of VanEck’s planned bitcoin ETF contains ‘surveillance-sharing agreement’ details similar to BlackRock’s proposed product


Annette Shaff/Shutterstock modified by Blockworks


VanEck has revised its spot bitcoin ETF bid in an effort to ease SEC concerns, though an executive at the fund group said the regulator should be treating all these filings the same. 

Asset management giant BlackRock piqued industry attention when it, for the first time, revealed plans to launch a spot bitcoin ETF. Others such as Bitwise, WisdomTree, Invesco and Valkyrie — who have previously attempted to bring to market such a product — re-upped their efforts in the following days.

Cboe, the exchange on which VanEck’s bitcoin ETF would trade, added language in its Thursday filing stating that it expects to enter into a surveillance-sharing agreement with “an operator of a United States-based spot trading platform for Bitcoin.”

Read more: How ‘surveillance-sharing’ is designed to deter bitcoin ETF manipulation 

The language is similar to that found in Nasdaq’s filing for the proposed BlackRock spot bitcoin ETF. Some have speculated the platform BlackRock is referring to is Coinbase, which would act as custodian for the proposed ETF’s bitcoin holdings. 

BlackRock and VanEck declined to comment.

“Perhaps the commercial attractiveness of working as custodian with an issuer as big as Blackrock may have convinced [Coinbase] to share data it previously didn’t want to share,” Matthew Sigel, VanEck’s head of digital assets research, said in a Thursday Twitter thread

He added: “Still, we see nothing unique/concrete in the proposed surveillance sharing agreement between Nasdaq [and] Coinbase which cannot be duplicated by other listing exchanges like the [Cboe] immediately.”

Similar to the proposed spot bitcoin ETF from VanEck, ETFs from WisdomTree, Invesco, Ark Invest, and 21Shares are also expected to trade on Cboe.

Valkyrie’s proposed spot bitcoin ETF, like BlackRock’s, would be listed on Nasdaq, while  Bitwise’s proposed spot bitcoin ETF would be listed on NYSE Arca.

‘Stop picking winners!’

The bitcoin futures ETF race put on display the reality of what industry participants refer to as “first-mover advantage.”

Gary Gensler said during the Aspen Security Forum in August 2021 that the SEC would “look forward” to reviewing filings limited to bitcoin futures contracts trading on the Chicago Mercantile Exchange (CME).

ProShares was the first to launch such a fund in October of that year — gathering roughly $1 billion on its first day — marking one of the most successful ETF launches ever. Similar funds that came to market in the following days failed to gain significant assets. 

Now in pursuit of a spot bitcoin ETF, prospective issuers continue jockeying for position to be first to market. 

“One problem with the SEC’s approach is that, without knowing the specific preconditions for approval, issuers have been almost continuously filing costly updates and re-filings, gambling that whoever is lucky enough to time their efforts closest to a regulatory change-of-heart might reap a multi-hundred-million-dollar revenue harvest,” Sigel said.

Attempts to launch a spot bitcoin ETF date back to a try by the Winklevoss twins in 2013. The SEC has blocked more than 30 similar filings in the past decade, according to Bloomberg Intelligence data. 

Sigel went as far to say in his Twitter thread that the SEC’s repeated rejections of spot bitcoin ETFs without clear reasoning is “potentially a denial of due process under the law.” 

Grayscale Investments is locked in a legal battle with the SEC — stemming from the regulator not permitting the conversion of its Bitcoin Trust (GBTC) to an ETF. 

“Given the nearly identical ETF applications submitted, we believe all issuers should have the same timeline to a bitcoin spot ETF,” Sigel added in a separate tweet. “Stop picking winners!”

Start your day with top crypto insights from David Canellis and Katherine Ross. Subscribe to the Empire newsletter.


Upcoming Events

Salt Lake City, UT

WED - FRI, OCTOBER 9 - 11, 2024

Pack your bags, anon — we’re heading west! Join us in the beautiful Salt Lake City for the third installment of Permissionless. Come for the alpha, stay for the fresh air. Permissionless III promises unforgettable panels, killer networking opportunities, and mountains […]

recent research

Screen Shot 2024-05-16 at 14.53.45.png


Loss-versus-rebalancing (LVR) is arguably Ethereum DeFi’s biggest problem, and thus reducing LVR is fundamental to the success of Ethereum. This report dives into the world of LVR. We uncover its importance for AMM designers, discuss the two major mechanism design categories and various projects developing solutions, and offer a higher level perspective on the importance of AMMs in general.


The memecoin platform is already back online, and Solana hit a monthly high following the exploit


Bitcoin was up around 2% over the past 24 hours at time of publication, according to data from Coinbase, to hit its highest price since late April


It’s in the best interest of our elected officials to cultivate that interest in crypto and incorporate these voters into a long-term political strategy


The courts adjourned the trials against Binance and Tigran Gambaryan until May 22 and May 23


Industry players have started realizing high-performance computing-related revenues as they buy Nvidia GPUs and secure customer deals


Yesterday saw Congress’ upper chamber side with the House on a measure aimed at overturning SAB 121