SEC overstepped its authority in Kraken case, state AGs allege

Eight state attorney generals warn the SEC’s enforcement actions could “stymie” potential state legislation around crypto

article-image

Iowa Attorney General Brenna Bird | Gage Skidmore/"Brenna Bird" (CC license)

share

The Securities and Exchange Commission exceeded “its delegated powers” in attempting to regulate “non-securities,” state attorney generals allege.

In an amicus brief filed in the regulatory agency’s case against Kraken’s parent company, eight state AGs pushed back against enforcement actions being taken by the agency in cases involving crypto. 

The SEC filed a suit against the parent companies in November of last year, alleging that Kraken operates as an unregistered exchange, commingled customer funds, and lists some cryptocurrencies that it claims are securities. 

Read more: SEC accuses Kraken of commingling customer funds, operating unregistered exchange

Montana Attorney General Austin Knudsen filed the brief, which was also supported by attorney generals from Texas, Iowa, Nebraska, Mississippi, South Dakota and Arkansas. 

The AGs clarify that they are not supporting either party in the case, due to the state of Montana taking “no position as to the conduct or business practices of Payward.”

However, the states take issue with the SEC’s regulation by enforcement approach, alleging that the agency has not been given the power to regulate crypto as a security. The arguments made in the filing echo previous arguments made in both Binance and Coinbase’s SEC suits.  

Read more: New lawsuit challenges SEC’s regulation by enforcement approach

The states oppose “SEC regulation of crypto assets absent an investment contract because Congress has not delegated that authority to the SEC.”

“The SEC’s exercise of this undelegated authority puts consumers at risk by potentially preempting state statutes better tailored to the specific risks of non-securities products. Some state laws are more protective of consumers than the federal securities laws,” the states alleged.

Gary Gensler’s agency has a handful of open court cases against crypto companies. In its cases against both Binance and Coinbase, it lists a number of the same tokens and alleges that they’re unregistered securities. The list includes ALGO, MATIC, ATOM, SOL, among others. 

Read more: Gensler’s SEC brought 46 crypto-related enforcements in 2023

The SEC’s “expansive interpretation of ‘investment contract’ would mean that Congress somehow intended the SEC to function as a general-purpose consumer protection regulator for any crypto asset where purchasers hope the value will increase,” Knudsen wrote.

The SEC’s “this over-reach will become increasingly problematic as the crypto-asset economy expands,” he continued. 

The brief cites Gensler’s previous comments on crypto asset regulation. 

“Exchanges trading in these crypto assets do not have a regulatory framework either at the SEC, or our sister agency, the Commodity Futures Trading Commission,” Gensler testified in 2021.

His testimony was also mentioned by Coinbase in August of last year when the exchange sought to dismiss the suit.

However, the states further point out that the SEC’s enforcement activity overlaps with “traditional state regulation.”

“States have a strong interest in preventing the potential preemption of consumer protection and other state laws by the SEC’s attempt to regulate crypto assets as securities,” Knudsen wrote. 

The states further allege that Gensler’s agency, while it does have the authority to oversee investment contracts, is trying to “ignore” limitations and “apply ‘investment contract’ to assets that do not meet the Howey definition.”

“The SEC’s attempted preemption of crypto assets also stymies state legislative experimentation in this area,” the AGs argued.

The SEC didn’t immediately return a request for comment.


Start your day with top crypto insights from David Canellis and Katherine Ross. Subscribe to the Empire newsletter.

Tags

Upcoming Events

Salt Lake City, UT

WED - FRI, OCTOBER 9 - 11, 2024

Pack your bags, anon — we’re heading west! Join us in the beautiful Salt Lake City for the third installment of Permissionless. Come for the alpha, stay for the fresh air. Permissionless III promises unforgettable panels, killer networking opportunities, and mountains […]

recent research

Screen Shot 2024-05-16 at 14.53.45.png

Research

Loss-versus-rebalancing (LVR) is arguably Ethereum DeFi’s biggest problem, and thus reducing LVR is fundamental to the success of Ethereum. This report dives into the world of LVR. We uncover its importance for AMM designers, discuss the two major mechanism design categories and various projects developing solutions, and offer a higher level perspective on the importance of AMMs in general.

article-image

Yesterday saw Congress’ upper chamber side with the House on a measure aimed at overturning SAB 121

article-image

Oklahoma’s new crypto bill will go into effect in November of this year

article-image

The deposits hit a $20 million cap in just 45 minutes

article-image

Twelve Democratic Senators voted in favor to pass the resolution Thursday

article-image

Pump.fun is “aware” that bonding curve contracts on Pump.fun were exploited, and has since paused trading

article-image

Some investment pros are mulling crypto allocations between 1% and 10% and seeking ex-BTC exposure for interested clients