Implement Web3 solutions now, or the media’s credibility will crumble

Web3 is our best hope to save the declining news media industry. By leveraging its associated technologies, we can introduce a new incentive system that addresses misinformation, bias and dwindling revenues. By introducing a new incentive system that rewards accuracy and builds public trust, we can save journalism from its current decline. If we fail to act, economic pressures could lead to its collapse.

In the digital age, news media often struggles to provide content that accurately informs the public it is meant to serve. With even the briefest introspection, it becomes clear just how dire the consequences already are for society. Many consumers have become passive in seeking out accuracy and truth, preferring instead to prioritize easy access to content that gratifies their immediate emotional desires.

Despite the resulting freefall in media trust, there is a growing awareness that the population is being manipulated. Unfortunately, those who reject mainstream media output often choose instead to turn to alternative sources — many of which are rife with conspiratorial messaging.

Read more from our opinion section: Blockchain can save the media

The problems in existing media can be traced back to centralized ownership and a reliance on business models that are poorly suited to truth-seeking. Traditional media outlets are controlled by a few authoritative entities, creating a hierarchical structure that manipulates content to suit the interests of those in power. Current models prioritize clicks and ad revenue over the accuracy and integrity of information, leading to a proliferation of fake news, bad data and sometimes outright propaganda.

But all is not lost. Web3 technologies can propel the media industry into a new age, where trust in the content we read online is restored through a healthier and more sustainable economic model. By creating a knowledge-sharing system underpinned by blockchain technology, decentralized identities and prediction markets, journalists will be freed from the control of media moguls.

Implementing decentralized mechanisms would ensure that all information is transparently recorded and cannot be altered retroactively. This would allow for increased transparency, which in turn would build trust among consumers who would be able to verify the authenticity and source of information themselves.

Both readers and journalists are starved for actionable methods to fulfill their demand for factual information. This is exemplified by legacy media platforms, many of which have invested in expert fact-checking divisions and community submission processes: CNN, Reuters and community notes on X, to name a few. However, such initiatives struggle to make progress due to the sheer amount of material that must be validated. Unfortunately, the truth doesn’t always pay, leading to conflicts of interest when it comes to reporting the facts.

Reputation-based systems can establish verifiable credentials without relying on centralized institutions and hone the crowd’s ability to deliver accurate information. Core participants would wield reputation scores that affect their ability to earn and contribute to the platform. Reputations would be built and maintained based on merit and accuracy, rather than affiliation with a particular media outlet.

To tackle disinformation, prediction markets could enable the crowd to evaluate the accuracy of stories and the credibility of their sources. By allowing people to bet on the outcomes of news stories or the validity of certain claims, these markets harness collective wisdom to weed out misinformation and highlight trustworthy content.

Research by MIT supports this idea, proving that crowdsourced accuracy judgments from groups of normal readers can be virtually as effective as the work of professional fact-checkers. Studies have shown that when economic incentives are offered to the crowd, its wisdom becomes even greater. By designing markets to prevent collusion and introducing participatory incentives for those with minority views, we can further enhance the predictive ability of the crowd.

We must also employ a funding mechanism rooted in decentralization and community involvement. This approach democratizes support for good-faith actors in news media while curbing the ability of bad actors to participate. As a result, we can expect greatly improved economic sustainability for journalists, aligning media incentives with the public interest rather than advertising revenue.

We should draw on the novel fundraising mechanism known as Quadratic Funding, invented by Vitalik Buterin, Zoe Hitzig and Glen Weyl. This model better reflects the community’s collective value by matching individual contributions using a quadratic formula to ensure that small contributions from many people achieve their maximum impact. This ensures that information is reviewed and funded democratically. The promise of this model lies in releasing journalists from the shackles of the advertising model, which is currently optimized for clicks above all else.

Finally, a decentralized media platform must implement robust decentralized identity protocols with proof-of-humanity included. These protocols ensure each user has a unique, verifiable identity, thus preventing Sybil attacks and the creation of multiple bot accounts by a single user. Anti-collusion infrastructure is essential to prevent groups of individuals from conspiring to manipulate outcomes in their favor. This helps the platform to remain fair and unbiased, protecting it from being hijacked by special interests.

The combination of these ideas will reduce the incentive to provoke emotional reactions aimed at securing greater advertising revenue. Instead, rewards will be determined by the accuracy and usefulness of the information provided. I fear that failure to adopt these Web3 technologies will result in the continued decline of the media industry, leading to a further loss of public trust, the spread of misinformation and the dominance of private agendas. It’s up to us to leverage the benefits inherent in Web3 technologies to save a crucial industry from failing before it is too late.

---

Start your day with top crypto insights from David Canellis and Katherine Ross. Subscribe to the Empire newsletter.

Explore the growing intersection between crypto, macroeconomics, policy and finance with Ben Strack, Casey Wagner and Felix Jauvin. Subscribe to the On the Margin newsletter.

The Lightspeed newsletter is all things Solana, in your inbox, every day. Subscribe to daily Solana news from Jack Kubinec and Jeff Albus.