Impermissibly Tainted? Gensler’s Own Words Could Bar Him From Crypto Securities Actions

Ripple and LBRY say Gensler’s comments show prejudgement in dealing with crypto cases

article-image

SEC Chair Gary Gensler | Source: Third Way "Gary Gensler" (CC license)

share

SEC Chair Gary Gensler, who has long hinted that he believes most crypto tokens are securities, finally confirmed his view that everything other than bitcoin falls under the SEC’s purview, and it’s giving crypto firms fuel for their legal battles. 

In a Feb. 23 interview with New York Magazine, Gensler confirmed what the industry has long expected: “Everything other than bitcoin” is a security, he said. 

In response to the comment, Ripple and LBRY, two firms who found themselves going head to head with the agency over this exact issue, are calling the agency chief’s behavior out as prejudiced. Ripple’s fight with the SEC is ongoing.

Gensler needs to recuse himself from all crypto enforcement action votes going forward, Ripple’s chief legal officer Stuart Alderoty argued. Alderoty cited the precedent established by Antoniu v. SEC, a case in which the SEC’s attempt to ban a stockbroker from working at a securities firm fell apart because a SEC commissioner had prejudged the case in a public statement.

In Antoniu, the plaintiff claimed that the commissioner’s participation in disbarment proceedings “impermissibly tainted the proceedings with the appearance of impropriety” and the court agreed, holding that the statements demonstrated that the commissioner “in some measure adjudged the facts as well as the law of a particular case in advance of hearing it.”

The court further stated that, “Accordingly, we nullify all Commission proceedings…in which Commissioner Cox participated occurring after Commissioner Cox’s speech was given and remand the case to the Commission with directions to make a de novo review of the evidence, without any participation by Commissioner Cox.”

If this precedent were to apply to Gensler’s speech, he may be prohibited from participating in future securities cases brought against digital asset firms.

The counter argument to Antoniu v. SEC is that although the commissioner in question recused himself from the proceedings after his speech, he did “participate in a routine denial of an offer of settlement,” University of Kentucky Law faculty wrote in a 2009 opinion. The commissioner’s actions “did nothing to violate the well-settled prejudgment doctrine about which the court writes,” faculty added. Their analysis, however, did not set a precedent.

LBRY, the issuer behind LBC Credit Tokens, also spoke up about Gensler’s NY Magazine comments, claiming the company knew Gensler’s opinion all along. 

Loading Tweet..

The situation comes after LBRY was handed down a summary judgment in November, which ruled in the SEC’s favor and confirmed LBC is a security. In a small win for LBRY, and potentially Ripple, in a January appeal, a judge clarified that secondary sales of LBC are not considered securities.

LBRY has publicly offered its help to other crypto agencies facing legal challenges with the SEC, saying it will share any information it can into the process and best practices when confronting enforcement actions. 

A summary judgment in Ripple’s case over the classification of its XRP is expected this year. The legal proceedings began in 2020.


Start your day with top crypto insights from David Canellis and Katherine Ross. Subscribe to the Empire newsletter.

Explore the growing intersection between crypto, macroeconomics, policy and finance with Ben Strack, Casey Wagner and Felix Jauvin. Subscribe to the Forward Guidance newsletter.

Get alpha directly in your inbox with the 0xResearch newsletter — market highlights, charts, degen trade ideas, governance updates, and more.

The Lightspeed newsletter is all things Solana, in your inbox, every day. Subscribe to daily Solana news from Jack Kubinec and Jeff Albus.

Tags

Upcoming Events

Javits Center North | 445 11th Ave

Tues - Thurs, March 18 - 20, 2025

Blockworks’ Digital Asset Summit (DAS) will feature conversations between the builders, allocators, and legislators who will shape the trajectory of the digital asset ecosystem in the US and abroad.

recent research

Flashnote Template Presentation (2).jpg

Research

With the recent election, it’s clear that there will be a meaningful shift in crypto regulations and legislation. Trump is likely as pro-crypto as a president can be. He launched (multiple) of his own NFT collections and is launching an Aave wrapper called World Liberty Fi. He has also spoken out and mentioned that he wants to make the United States "the crypto capital of the planet" and transform it into the "Bitcoin superpower of the world". He proposed creating a strategic national Bitcoin stockpile alongside support from Senator Cynthia Lummis, promising to retain 100% of all Bitcoin held by the U.S. government. More importantly, we’re likely to see deregulation across the board in a lot of industries, with crypto being one of them - as Trump has committed to keeping the crypto market largely unregulated. Crypto, DeFi in particular, has historically been knee-capped by overreaching and hostile governmental agencies and regulation by enforcement, as evidenced by the plethora of Wells notices and lawsuits over the past few years. With Donald Trump winning the presidency, Republicans taking control of the Senate, and being on the verge of securing the House, we think it’s likely that crypto realizes positive regulatory clarity. Below, you can find our analysts’ takes:

article-image

Researcher Justin Drake’s Beam Chain proposal aims to transform Ethereum’s consensus layer with zk proofs and post-quantum cryptography

article-image

Gunzilla’s Theodore Agranat said that blockchain technology helps “enhance’ gamer experience

article-image

BTC continues to smash expectations as it holds near $90,000

article-image

Inflation is higher than it was in 2016, and the Fed is just at the beginning of its rate-cutting cycle

article-image

Bitwise’s Matt Hougan expects BTC to hit $100,000 by the end of the year and continue upward in 2025

article-image

Midwest Blockchain Week showed the depth of talent available at US universities while focusing on how memecoins could bring back the retail investor