Months After De-Pegging Event, USDC Continues to Lag Behind Tether

Tether’s recent market share gains seem to be directly at the expense of Circle’s USDC


Source: Shutterstock / CryptoFX, modified by Blockworks


Reflecting on events like the Terra collapse in the spring of 2022 and the de-pegging of USDC less than a year later might cause one to question the accuracy of the term “stablecoin.”

Despite the tumult, the most popular stablecoin token, Tether’s USDT (USDT), continued growing in market share while competitors faltered. It began the year with a market cap of $66 billion, and now exceeds $82 billion. Much of these gains seem to be directly at the expense of Circle’s stablecoin offering, USDC (USDC), which began the year with a market cap of $44 billion but has since fallen to just under $30 billion.

Bitwise CIO Matt Hougan and crypto research analyst Ryan Rasmussen discussed USDC’s momentary depegging from the dollar and its potential long-term implications in an interview with Blockworks on the 0xResearch podcast.

“We at no time had real fundamental worries about how it would shake out in the end,” says Hougan. “My only concern was that it would damage their reputation.” 

Liquidity issues related to regional bank failures were reportedly the primary cause of USDC’s brief period of instability. Hougan says he feared onlookers would assume the USDC depegging event was a crypto-native failure, like the aforementioned Terra algorithmic stablecoin meltdown, rather than a traditional finance failure. 

“That turned out not to be the case. I think everyone has confidence in USDC, more confidence even today than they did back then because they’ve improved their collateral.”

“But yeah, I wish USDT wasn’t gaining market share.”

Markets are rewarding opacity

Hougan says it’s bad for the market “when you reward opacity.” People perceived Tether as a safer place for their money, he says, “because they couldn’t see that they couldn’t access their money. That’s terrible reasoning.”

“I wish it would go the other way. I think it will over time. I still believe in that.”

Hougan believes institutions will become a larger part of the market. “People want more regulated entities.”

Rasmussen says regional bank failures and USDC’s subsequent liquidity problems did, in fact, harm its reputation. It was “a ripple effect,” he says, of Silicon Valley Bank’s “not so great risk management.”

According to Rasmussen, an important lesson was derived by Circle from the fiasco: “Spreading your capital across multiple banks as a stablecoin issuer probably makes a lot more sense” than concentrating funds in one place, “especially a regional bank.”

He states that USDC now holds a “huge portion” of its capital in treasuries. “You’re really getting a very similar risk profile from exposure to the traditional financial system with either stablecoin,” he says.

Rasmussen presents factors for choosing between USDT and USDC, “Which one has less opacity? Which one has less regulatory risk?”

“USDC wins that battle every single time.”

Hougan laments the current regulatory climate in America and how it’s holding back companies that are attempting to comply. “USDC is doing the best job of trying to be a regulated, audited, clearly accessible entity.”

“That doesn’t actually necessarily mean in today’s climate that it has lower regulatory risk.”

“You’re not necessarily rewarded for trying to do the right thing in today’s crypto environment. I wish that weren’t the case, but this is an imperfect market that we all operate in.”

Podcast host Dan Smith adds, “I did think it was very interesting that during the USDC de-peg, USDT was the safe haven. And that would imply that at the time Tether had no exposure to the US banking system.” 

“Whether that’s a good thing or a bad thing is definitely up in the air.”

Get the day’s top crypto news and insights delivered to your email every evening. Subscribe to Blockworks’ free newsletter now.

Want alpha sent directly to your inbox? Get degen trade ideas, governance updates, token performance, can’t-miss tweets and more from Blockworks Research’s Daily Debrief.

Can’t wait? Get our news the fastest way possible. Join us on Telegram and follow us on Google News.


upcoming event

MON - WED, MARCH 18 - 20, 2024

Digital Asset Summit (DAS) is returning March 2024. This year’s event will be held in our nation’s capital, where industry leaders, policymakers, and institutional experts will come together to discuss the latest developments and challenges in the ever-evolving world of cryptocurrency. […]

upcoming event

MON - WED, SEPT. 11 - 13, 2023

2022 was a meme.Skeptics danced, believers believed.Eventually, newcomers turned away, drained of liquidity and hope.Now, the tide is shifting and it’s time to rebuild. Permissionless II is the brainchild of Blockworks and Bankless. It’s not just a conference, but a call […]

recent research

The State of LSTFi


There are five broad use cases for LSTs that are gaining traction alongside growth in demand: leverage farming, liquidity providing, LST baskets, stablecoin collateral, and interest rate derivatives.



Alexander Vinnik’s lawyers aim to swap his freedom for detained WSJ reporter Evan Gershkovich


This latest update will introduce immutability to token metadata but ensure that its key characteristics are preserved, and it will also introduce network fees


In a blog post, partly directed at the forthcoming Eigenlayer protocol, the Ethereum co-founder cautions against overloading consensus


Hunting for victims in Ethereum’s public mempool, automated searchers prey on transactions as they are discovered in a practice called MEV


The crypto exchange that filed for bankruptcy last November would endure a long road to raise funds, clear debts and gain trust, law pros say


The broadcasters were discussing Hong Kong’s new regulations for virtual asset trading platforms set to go into effect June 1