Is Crypto Fueling Corruption or Helping Citizens Flee It?
IMF study finds crypto adoption is more prevalent in countries with higher corruption and capital controls. But why?
- The study considered seven variables to account for a prevalence for crypto adoption in 53 countries to determine which were most significant
- The IMF also highlighted the role cryptoassets can play in providing transparency for procurement or other payments related to government projects
Cryptoassets have “unleashed a plethora of financial innovation that will likely revolutionize the form of money and the ways it is used,” a recently published International Monetary Fund report said, but the multilateral lender cautioned that, without regulation, cryptoassets may also facilitate illicit capital flows.
In an alliteratively titled working paper — Crypto, Corruption, and Capital Controls: Cross-Country Correlations — IMF researchers concluded that, based on crypto usage data drawn from Statista’s Global Consumer Survey, “cryptoasset usage is significantly and positively associated with corruption and capital controls.”
But the paper goes beyond identifying correlation to say that “that cryptoassets may be used to transfer corruption proceeds or circumvent capital controls” and calls on regulators to “bring empirical evidence to bear on the question of whether cryptoassets facilitate corruption.”
The researchers noted that cryptocurrencies are hardly unique in that respect, though, pointing out that the anonymity of cash, especially large denomination notes, is exploited for crime and tax evasion.
Interpretation is key
The authors evaluated crypto adoption depending on seven variables, including inflation rates, remittances and GDP per capita, but determined that control of corruption and capital controls are clearly the most significant factors.
The question for regulators is, what accounts for the correlation?
“While there are certainly examples of bad actors using cryptoassets to circumvent oversight, these individuals are not the driving factor for the higher rates of crypto adoption we’re seeing in countries with prevalent corruption,” said Budd White, chief product officer and co-founder at Tacen, a Wyoming crypto compliance firm.
The IMF report’s authors found both factors were practically indistinguishable in terms of their significance within the survey data. But the practical implementation of capital controls is itself a highly nuanced affair, according to Gabriella Kusz, CEO of the Global Digital Asset and Cryptocurrency Association. Just because capital controls exist doesn’t mean they are functioning well, she told Blockworks.
Transparency is commonly considered an antidote to corruption, and the paper notes that “these technologies could also be used to improve transparency and record-keeping for procurement or other payments related to government projects, thereby increasing accountability, and reducing the scope for corruption.”
That puts the IMF framing squarely in the “blockchain not crypto” school of thought. The authors specifically mention the potential of central bank digital currencies (CBDC) to “offer additional resilience, safety and availability with lower costs,” concluding that “work should continue in using the technologies underlying crypto assets to realize the potential benefits to financial inclusion and the efficiency of governments.”
The authors analyzed data from surveys of 2,000 to 12,000 people in 53 countries. They highlight a need for better data on adoption trends, citing limitations of earlier studies and a lack of sufficient high-quality data.
Yet, regulators should not wait for “conclusive evidence,” the authors contend, but should consider “the urgency of acting before it’s too late.”
However, the efficiency benefits of a CBDC are only useful in the absence of corruption. For a citizen fleeing a corrupt regime, attempting to preserve the value of their savings, the censorship resistance inherent to crypto is paramount.
So, the question becomes, “too late for whom?”
Don’t miss the next big story – join our free daily newsletter.