Would Uniswap be better off on its own appchain?

The appchain model gives the community true “ownership of the application,” Blockworks Research analyst David Rodriguez argues

article-image

Vector-3D/Shutterstock modified by Blockworks

share

The latest improvements to Uniswap, the largest decentralized crypto exchange by volume, are on their way, with draft code recently released for the community to scrutinize. 

The V4 update will introduce a number of improvements, including “hooks” — smart contracts that interact and build on top of custom pools — and architectural efficiencies that should significantly reduce gas costs.

So once V4 is settled, what’s coming up for Uniswap?

On a recent Empire podcast (Spotify / Apple), Blockworks research analyst David Rodriguez says the next “obvious step” would be for Uniswap to operate its own appchain.

Owning and operating “the entire stack,” as opposed to running on Ethereum, provides important advantages, Rodriguez says. 

“Not only can you potentially monetize at every layer of the stack, but because you own that full stack, you’re actually able to have full customization of your application.”

On an appchain like those offered in the Cosmos ecosystem, applications and chains are “aware of each other,” Rodriguez explains. “So there’s application-specific logic that you can bake into how your chain actually comes to consensus.”

Bending the knee

Rodriguez mentions one example of the difficulties of operating on the Ethereum network with the upcoming “singleton contract” under V4. It reduces gas fees by allowing tokens to be transferred via a single contract instead of between pools held in different smart contracts. 

But to enable the most efficient routing, he says, Uniswap “needs transient storage to be baked into Ethereum.”

Such a particular change to the Ethereum network could be perceived as “catering to a specific protocol,” Rodriguez says.

The research analyst says past arguments regarding this issue centered on whether Ethereum should be “bending the knee to Uniswap,” changing its roadmap to prioritize the popular DeFi primitive over other applications in the ecosystem.

If the Uniswap community simply wants to build the best product, it can build its own full stack on an appchain and operate independently of other network demands, Rodriguez says. 

“You don’t have to start politicizing or lobbying for a reason why your specific op code that you want in Ethereum needs to go ahead of others.”

The appchain model gives the community true “ownership of the application,” Rodriguez argues. “Whereas right now, everything that’s built on Ethereum is really at the mercy of Ethereum.”

Capturing value

Blockworks research analyst Ren Yu Kong disagrees. “V4, to me, signifies that Uniswap may not go to an appchain model,” he says.

The major reason for a DeFi application to move to the appchain model would be for “value capture,” Kong says. 

That is accomplished in two ways, Kong says. Either through the “internalization of MEV” — where value from network activities is returned to the protocol rather than external MEV actors — or turning on a fee switch.

Under V4’s improvements, Kong says, the “hook” smart contract improvement allows for some internalization of MEV — a narrative that is being “publicly pushed by Uniswap themselves,” with Uniswap-backer Paradigm Capital’s Dan Robinson promoting the approach, Kong says.

“Now you have withdrawal fees. Now you have swap fees.” Protocols that launch hooks can capture both, he says.

“If Uniswap’s allowing all of these liquidity pool launchers to do that, then maybe they aren’t that concerned about value capture,” Kong says.

“Maybe there’s not so much need for an appchain.”


Start your day with top crypto insights from David Canellis and Katherine Ross. Subscribe to the Empire newsletter.

Explore the growing intersection between crypto, macroeconomics, policy and finance with Ben Strack, Casey Wagner and Felix Jauvin. Subscribe to the Forward Guidance newsletter.

Get alpha directly in your inbox with the 0xResearch newsletter — market highlights, charts, degen trade ideas, governance updates, and more.

The Lightspeed newsletter is all things Solana, in your inbox, every day. Subscribe to daily Solana news from Jack Kubinec and Jeff Albus.

Tags

Upcoming Events

Javits Center North | 445 11th Ave

Tues - Thurs, March 18 - 20, 2025

Blockworks’ Digital Asset Summit (DAS) will feature conversations between the builders, allocators, and legislators who will shape the trajectory of the digital asset ecosystem in the US and abroad.

recent research

kamino cover.jpg

Research

Kamino has solidified its position as the leading money market on Solana and is emerging as a DeFi bluechip. Although DeFi competition is fierce, Kamino has kept iterating on its product to provide the best-in-class UX, paired with a robust risk management framework and battle-tested infrastructure. Given the rollout of Kamino Lend V2, the protocol may scale aggressively over the coming months, penetrating previously untapped markets in Solana DeFi.

article-image

Paxos CEO Charles Cascarilla’s open letter hits a little different as voters get set to cast their ballots next week

article-image

VanEck will now offer regulated access to solana staking rewards on top of the price of SOL

article-image

The upgrade strengthens Stacks’ alignment with Bitcoin’s security, paving the way for sBTC and new bitcoin DeFi possibilities

article-image

Option premiums and estimated daily volatility for bitcoin are projected to rise significantly around Nov. 6-8

article-image

Betting on opinions will make sentiment analysis more valuable and honest

article-image

Base DEX volumes have now eclipsed Kraken’s